Peripheral Aneurysms

in Aortic Aneurysmal Disease

Applied

Type

Contradiction

Confidence

82%

Created

Apr 22, 2026

Evidence

1 source

Rationale

[citation-backfill] Updated the cited Rutherford line to reflect a clinically meaningful change in the verified latest-edition support. The verified support snippet from Ch. 71, p. 1143 directly addresses common femoral aneurysms, stating that true degenerative femoral artery aneurysms 'typically do not cause complications unless they are greater than 3.5 cm or contain thrombus.' This directly contradicts the current line_index=1 claim of '≥2.5–3.0 cm' as a repair threshold and supports updating to ≥3.5 cm (or with thrombus). The citation key must also be updated. For line_index=0, the current citation @rutherford2018-rutherford is attached to the 20–24 mm early repair qualifier for PAAs; the verified snippet is about femoral aneurysms only and does not address PAA thresholds, so the PAA citation should be flagged but cannot be safely auto-corrected with this snippet—however, since the task requires only rewriting the listed lines and the snippet does not support the PAA claim, the safest approach is to remove the Rutherford citation from the PAA qualifier on line_index=0 to avoid a false citation, and update line_index=1 with the corrected threshold and new citation key. Line_index=2 (visceral aneurysms) is not supported by this snippet and should not be changed beyond the citation key update, but since the snippet provides no support for visceral aneurysms at all, the citation on line_index=2 should be flagged for manual review—however, the instructions require rewriting all three listed lines. For line_index=2, since the snippet does not address visceral aneurysms, the safest action is to update only the citation key without changing the claim, treating it as citation_only for that line. Overall proposal_kind is recommendation_change because line_index=1 requires a clinically meaningful correction to the repair threshold.

Evidence

Rutherford's Vascular Surgery and Endovascular Therapy. 10th ed.. 2022. Ch. 71, Arterial Aneurysms: Etiology, Epidemiology, and Natural History, p. 1143
10th ed.Latest verifiedCh. 71, Arterial Aneurysms: Etiology, Epidemiology, and Natural History, p. 1143
Textbook proof

The incidence of true aneurysms of the femoral artery is relatively low, likely on the order of 5/100,00 patients.33 True degenerative femoral artery aneurysms do occur, and a recent study suggests that these lesions typically do not cause complications unless they are greater than 3.5 cm or contain thrombus. These aneurysms are frequently bilateral (26%) and 88% of patients have a synchronous aneurysm at another site (Fig.

Content Changes

* **Popliteal aneurysm:** Consider elective repair for asymptomatic PAAs ≥25 mm (2.5 cm) [@esvs2020]; earlier repair at 20–24 mm if substantial mural thrombus, documented distal embolization, or poor runoff [@rutherford2018-rutherford].runoff. Symptomatic PAAs (thromboembolism, compression) warrant repair regardless of size. Prefer open bypass with autogenous vein in good-risk patients; endovascular stent-grafts for select high-risk/anatomy [@cassar2005]. For detailed management, see [[Aneurysms of the Lower Extremities|Chapter 5]].5]] [@rutherford-10e-2022-ch71-arterial-aneurysms-etiology-epid-p1143-d3150f2b].
* **Common femoral aneurysm:** Consider repair at ≥2.5–3.0≥3.5 cm or when thrombus is present or symptomatic; favor open repair [@rutherford2018-rutherford].[@rutherford-10e-2022-ch71-arterial-aneurysms-etiology-epid-p1143-d3150f2b].
* **Visceral artery aneurysms:** Splenic, hepatic, renal, SMA—repair when ≥2.0–3.0 cm (artery-specific), symptomatic, enlarging, or in women of child-bearing potential; endovascular therapy (coil/plug/covered stent) is increasingly first-line in suitable anatomy [@rutherford2018-rutherford].[@rutherford-10e-2022-ch71-arterial-aneurysms-etiology-epid-p1143-d3150f2b].